I don't think any of us mods have an issue with pointing out a player's fault. I haven't had any real arguments with pigsah or nasty or anyone else. For me it's been civilized debate.
The problem I see and the way it rubs us wrong is the way it comes out and comes across. It just feels a little more aggressive towards Matt than it does other guys and my problem with it is that Matt is the one painted in a corner. He's in a role that we've all agreed he probably won't be in for long and probably shouldn't have to be in. Due to circumstances though he is. In my personal opinion, I'd rather appreciate his plight rather than bury him and that's just how it feels. Feels like he gets buried and all he's doing is what's asked of him.
No arguments, just sensitive to his situation. That's how I view it.