I also am not a big fan of the 4th and 1 at the what, northwestern 43, going for it. In two offensive series, you held Northwestern to one first down. I am a big believer in if you cannot get a yard, you do not deserve to win, but I think the possible repercussions of not making it outweigh the benefits. You have a great punter and Duke has all the momentum. Pin Northwestern deep. Thank God when Northwestern made the stop, it didn’t do anything after, but I do not like the possibility of needlessly handing the Wildcats a short field and momentum.
I am glad to see our fg kicker get a chance and nail a decently long field goal. Missing what was just a little more than an extra point last week against Lafayette could have turned into a mental thing if the kicker could not “get back on the horse”relatively soon.
That unsportsmanlike was an early Christmas present for those that had the over.
I am glad our punter got in the game. He seems like he will be a secret weapon in those grind it out games. Seems very good at flipping the field when we need it. But to be among NCAA leaders, you need to play in 75% of games. He holds on kicks, but if that is all someone does, that technically is not a game played. If all you do is hold and the kicks get off as intended (no penalty, fake, blocked kick, etc…), per NCAA stat rules it does not count as a game participation. Added so backup QB holders are not penalized in per game stats because all they did was simply hold on kicks. Had he not punted yesterday, our punter has only played in one of three games this year.
There can not be enough emphasis on that drive to begin the third. We were “only” up 17-7 (but I would argue with what it took to score for Northwestern, it was a UVA basketball thing where a 10 point lead is bigger than it seems), but Duke made sure It had all the momentum by going right down the field.
We have only given up 28 points this year, but one could argue it should be half that (take away a muffed punt and a stupid unsportsmanlike, and there you go). That is scary to think about.
As for Elko rumors, I think we will not see him leave. Duke has alums with deep pockets. We can live off great grad transfers as our academics are top notch, and one 7-5 or 8-4 season won’t put you on the hot seat like at a lot of SEC schools. Like Billy D in basketball was shielded by being at a football school in the early 2000s, any football coach has a bit of cover because we are a basketball school. One could argue that gave Cut 1 or 2 more years than he probably deserved…