Back in tha day...
Dear Chancellor Thorp,
Like most faculty I am concerned for the reputation of the University. I heard you say those words in your presentation in the televised news conference but have not seen any definitive actions that back up those statements. I have been a faculty member for 31 years. I also played a varsity sport (baseball) in college at the division I level.
There has been a problem here in the football program since the day that I arrived. A neighbor of mine in Colony Woods was a Political Science professor who had a lot of players in his course. Somehow he always managed to ride in the front of the team's private chartered jet even though he was of modest means and the players who took his course {there were several) always passed.
A math professor who lived across the street told me about a famous running back who did not quality to take algebra 1 who cheated on the final exam in a "kiddie" math course that he wasn't even taking for credit. His case went before the honor court so it is a matter of record.
My next door neighbor now a Political Science professor at Emory, was called by an assistant football coach and asked to change a famous running backs grade. You are welcome to call as I'm sure he wouldn't mind telling you the story.
The former baseball coach told me that two of the most famous football players did not have combined SAT scores over 1000.This was before the current rules that don't permit that to occur.
My point is that your statement that implied in the past we have always done the right thing while maybe politically necessary at the moment misses the mark. This problem has been around a long time. Bill Friday talks about just about every week.
Because it has been around a long time and Dickie Baddour has worked here longer than 1 have he has known about it for at least as long as I have. What measures did he take when he became athletic director to do something about it? I am not interested in what he is doing now that his feet are being held to the fire I want to know what he did the first month he was on the job? What were Dickie's credentials for that job other than the fact that he was well liked by the employees in the athletic office? Sure he is a nice guy but how much respect does a big time football coach who is used to getting pretty much getting his way with everything have for his opinion?
A former head of the Rams club told me that Coach Davis made some outrageous financial requests when he got here that Dickie said yes to everything and he got what he requested. Some other people in the athletic program weren't real happy about that but so much for Coach Davis being a team player. Is it ridiculous to assume that if a bunch of 19 year olds observe that kind of behavior that maybe they will think they are entitled to go to a "free party in Miami?"
As faculty and loyal supporters of the University I and my colleagues are counting on you to do the right thing. You have already lost precious time and every day that you wait to make a decision only damages your own credibility and that of the University.
If there is no evidence that either Dick Baddour or coach Davis did anything substantive prospectively to prevent this then there is only one decision that will clear the air and restore some measure of respect which this University truly deserves.
Sincerely,
David Clemmons
Kenan Professor of Medicine
From: Thorp, Holden Sent: Monday, September 06, 2010 5:52 PM
To: Clemmons, David R
Subject: RE: The integrity of UNC
David,
Thanks for your note, I am deeply concerned about the situation. We will keep working diligently until we get this straightened out.
Holden