I like Scheyer, but I think Capel deserves it. He was part of making Duke cool again on the recruiting trail and he has head coaching and NCAA Tournament experience. If you love experience, Scheyer isn’t the man for the job at the moment.
Too many eyes will be on Duke after K retires for Capel to be able Head Coach. Between his issues at Oklahoma, and all the noise regarding recruiting when Capel was leading the charge at Duke, the writers who would let things slide because of their respect for K would be all over Capel at Duke.
Scheyer doesn’t have that negative reputation in the recruiting world that could dirty us up once K is gone and he takes over. Hate it for Jeff but there just isn’t enough upside to take that risk.